Review: Initiate: A Witch’s Circle of Water by Thuri Calafia

I picked this up about a year ago because a friend was reading it and I thought maybe I could adapt some of the material in it to suit my own practice. It’s been sitting on my desk with part of my to-read pile, but since it’s warm enough to read outside now (Happy Solstice!) I’ve been spending a lot of time working on it. Unfortunately, I have long suspected my books are reproducing.

Initiate might seem like an odd choice of book for a Vanatruar, and it is, it’s meant to be a year and a day course of study in solitary eclectic Wicca, specifically the rough equivalent of second degree material (although each tradition has their own take on degrees). In short, this book is meant to be Wicca 201, the sort of book that isn’t geared towards beginners that folks are constantly asking for, or at least they were when I identified as Wiccan.

Initiate is divided up into three main sections: a lunar year that includes inner work and exercises over thirteen moons, a solar year which focuses on holidays and more outward expressions of the religion, and the adept initiation itself. Students are meant to use the lunar and solar lessons in tandem to get the full year and a day study experience. Much of the book is focused on energy work, chasing one’s shadows, and preparing for the service and community oriented adept path. Some topics covered in the book include examining your attitude towards money (including whether or not to charge for services), sexuality, devotion, health and healing. and more.

As someone who has read a lot of Wicca 101 books, this book is definitely one I could have used back then. It assumes you’ve read Dedicant, the author’s first book, or at least that you already know the stuff outlined in typical 191 books. This book is meant to address what comes next after initiation. This is something that is sorely lacking in the market these days. There are lots of books that tell you how to cast a circle, but few that tell you what to do when you’ve taken that big step and been initiated or dedicated yourself to a Wiccan tradition, and there is definitely some food for thought here. I think it’s important to examine one’s attitudes towards money, for instance, especially since I’ve seen some very unhealthy attitudes towards money since becoming a Pagan.

Unfortunately I felt that the book would have been way more enjoyable if the author’s voice wasn’t so prominent throughout. That sounds like a strange thing to say, but she comes across as somewhat condescending, referring to readers as “dear initiate” more than a hundred times in the book, and in some places becomes almost preachy (particularly in the section on health and healing. Other things I felt could have been worded better, such as the statement that we need to look after the mentally ill, as if everyone with a mental illness is incapable of caring for themselves. Other issues I had with the book can be chalked up to my issues with Wicca as a whole, namely gender essentialism (in particular, stating that “by nature and nurture” men naturally project energy, women naturally receive energy). I also found her “look up community things on the internet!” advice to be pretty unhelpful, as not everyone knows how to search for reliable information on the internet. This is purely my personal preference, but i think I would have preferred it if the solar and lunar years were together in one section since they relate to each other anyways, and I can see a student getting annoyed with having to constantly flip back and forth between them. The stories at the beginning of each chapter did well highlighting the major theme in that chapter but I found them to be a bit corny. The glossary at the back is a godsend because the author uses some different words for common Wiccan concepts that you might not see in other books, but I take issue with some of the entries, particularly the one for “matron” goddesses, as the author does not seem to understand why using “matron” to refer to patron deities is incorrect and potentially insulting to said deities.

Initiate is not a book that I need at this time, but it was a book that I would have loved in the past. i do think it asks some interesting questions, and for a solitary Wiccan looking for ways to deepen their practice, you could certainly do worse than this book. Unfortunately, I ultimately felt that any good advice this book had to offer was drowned out by the author’s voice. Still, if you know someone who is looking for a Wicca 201 book, they might want to check it out, and in case you’re worried that this is going to be a regular thing, don’t worry, I have a more tradition appropriate book coming up soon (it’s Norse Goddess Magic A.K.A. Magic of the Norse Goddesses by Alice Karlsdottir).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s